voice acting? is shit lol

this looks? fucking stupid, read it or watch the movie this is just a joke lmao

There is something you could only see if animated: The moving figures of rorschach? mask :)

wow really, i'm reading the Graphic novel right when i could just watch it. :( this blows i have to say i saw the movie first, now that i'm reading the comic i'm useing the actors voices from the movies.? I like the guy who plays rorshach. :) he's a BADASS,

Jeez everybody gets so faggy about watchmen, calm? the fuck down

I get what you say, after all it is your perception regarding the story and it is valid. I better go check the comic to know how good it really is storywise. Though I would still? not make a direct comparison :)

It's the same story, so? the comparison is valid if you are talking about that. As a media, you can still compare. Both of them are graphic, one static and the other with motion and sound (quite a clichéd soundtrack, unfortunately). It is different when you "translate" words to video, but that's not the case here. In any case, I'm not complaining visually. Very well done, here. But as a story, nowhere near the original. Your approach is biased and a bit naive, but thanks still.

They're different media, follow different rules, it's not wise to? make that kind of comparison, one should judge them sepparately. It;s a very common mistake, that we all seem to make now and then.

Why? does everyone sound constipated in this?

No way is this better than the graphic novel. Alan and Dave crammed in a lot of techniques that could only be done in a comic and would simply never survive the translation to any other medium, which resulted in both the film and the motion comic being no where? near as deep.

I'll take the graphic novel thanks, I tried this motion comic and just couldn't finish it because of the subpar narrator, plus them leaving out whole chunks of the graphic novel like 'A Man On Fifteen Dead Men's Chest' (which gives the whole back story of The 'Tales of The Black Freighter' comics) and 'Under The Hood' The motion comic just really came up short for me. I had read DC has made Watchmen available for downloading on an E-Book Reader ?!?? That should be..... interesting.

I thoroughly enjoyed this collection. I really hope they do more like it? for other comics.

I really hate their vioces..? Just me.

My? opinion on arguing 'bout which is better, motion comics or comic books. (On youtube) /watch?v=BNsrK6P9QvI

I'd love to try making a motion comic. This? stuff looks pretty cool.

Liked watchmen? bought d live action film ultimate cut own d comic n juz bought d action comic it was good but hated d way they used man voices on female character . Why the hell would dey do such a thing???

Why is everyone complaining that this is just for people who are to lazy to pick up the book? I read the graphic novel and THEN watched this, and personally, I prefer this. Not because I'm too lazy to read or anything, but this just totally brings the comic to life! The colors, the movements, the music, hell even the narrator's voice! It's all just mesmerizing to me! I think it's amazing? and anyone who is a fan of Watchmen should really give it a try.

better than that crummy movie ?

This is for those sad people who are too lazy? to read anymore. I mean, c'mon! Read the original for chrissake!

i love watchmen but this cartoon was very disappointing! crap? even!

its not even the complete complete novel frame by frame as they say they cutter a few frames and dialogs form each chapter :(! but more complete than the movie... it works for lazy guys who? dont want to read!

hahaha (this is not a complain to you xD, but) how could the "movie" be better than the NOVEL when the movie was "based" on the novel and even so , the movie its kind of a summary not the complete idea and cutted all supportive characters... Novel= Awesome, movie= something you might want to watch before reading the novel to get a brief? idea of what the novel is...

I don't why is everybody complaining about the Motion Comic. It was great, you're right about the females voices, but besides that, it was awesome! The music? fits perfectly and the narrator did a great job for male characters. I totally loved the Chapter IV, the voice he gives to Dr. Manhattan was terrific!

LOL the? voice acting for Rorschach is shit!

no matter what you do with it, how you remix it or move it, it is never gonna be better than the original comic book. Constant moving camera just makes it worse and voices in your head when you read it are so much better and quite more real than this clumzy voiceover... It? is just another poor moneymaker from one licence of such a good novel.